نوع مقاله : مروری
عنوان مقاله English
نویسندگان English
The prohibition of torture, as a jus cogens and absolute norm, holds a foundational role in safeguarding human dignity. Its conceptualization and implementation across regional human rights systems, deeply influenced by institutional structures and distinct historical trajectories, have shaped diverse interpretive patterns and a sophisticated body of jurisprudence. This research examines how the European and Inter-American human rights systems delineate the threshold between torture and other forms of ill-treatment, while simultaneously reinforcing states’ positive obligations concerning effective prevention, prompt and impartial investigation, and judicial accountability. Employing a descriptive-analytical method combined with a functionalist comparative approach, this study evaluates the constituent instruments, supervisory mechanisms, and evolving case law of both systems. Findings indicate that the European system has systematized the distinctions between torture, inhuman, and degrading treatment—utilizing dynamic interpretation to respond to contemporary societal shifts—while categorically rejecting any derogations based on security or emergency. Conversely, the Inter-American system adopts a distinct victim-centric approach, emphasizing the presumption of state responsibility for injuries sustained during detention, recognizing the psychological, sexual, and cultural dimensions of torture, and prioritizing restorative justice and comprehensive structural reparations. Ultimately, while both systems significantly consolidate the global prohibition of torture, the European system exceeds in institutionalizing preventive measures, whereas the Inter-American system leads in developing innovative, reparative judicial mechanisms.
کلیدواژهها English