The Necessity of Criminalizing the Phenomenon of Cyberbullying in Iranian and American Criminal Law

Hoseini, Seyede Ameneh; Zandi, Mohammad Reza; Tadayyon, Abbas

doi:10.22096/law.2023.553437.2043

The Necessity of Criminalizing the Phenomenon of Cyberbullying in Iranian and American Criminal Law

Document Type : Research Article

Authors

Seyede Ameneh Hoseini ¹

Mohammad Reza Zandi ²

Abbas Tadayyon ²

¹ Ph.D Candidate in Criminology and Criminal Law, Isalamic Azad University, Department of Criminal Law and Criminology, Central Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran.

² Assistant Professor, Department of Criminal Law and Criminology, Central Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran.

10.22096/law.2023.553437.2043

Abstract

Cyberbullying is any violent behavior with the abuse of power in cyberspace, which often, anonymously and repeatedly, causes harassment and intimidation to the victim. This phenomenon has been criminalized in US criminal law at the state level and only in some states independently. But at the federal level, examples of criminal behavior such as online harassment have been criminalized. In Iranian criminal law, there are no crimes under the headings of bullying, classic, and cyberbullying, and only in Articles 617 and 618 of the Islamic Penal Code, Articles 4 and 5 of the Audiovisual Law approved in 2007, some examples were scattered. The purpose of this study is to express the necessity of criminalizing the phenomenon of cyberbullying and to evaluate and analyze the relevant legal materials in this regard in Iranian and American criminal law. Findings in this study indicate that physical behavior in cyberbullying is in the form of state and through methods such as severe harassment, defamation and dissemination of private information, deprivation, forgery, and indirect threats appear on the scene. In addition, the existence of a dangerous situation for the perpetrator as well as the harmful consequences of cyberbullying, the difference between cyberspace and real space, the inadequacy of existing laws and principles such as the principle of harm, the principle of legality of crime and punishments, the need for differential and independent criminalization, justify this phenomenon.

Keywords

Bullying

Cyberbullying in Cyberspace

Cyberstalking

Threat

Bibliography

Agnieszka, Grzasko. “On the sematic history of selected terms of endearment.” Linguistic beyond and within 1 (2015): 104-118, https://doi.org/10.31743/lingbaw.5626.

Aiman El Asam, and Muthanna Samara. “Cyberbullying and the Law: A Review of Psychological and Legal Challenges, Department of Psychology, Kingston University London.”Computer in human behavior 65 (2016): 127 -141, http://doi,irg/10.1016.08. 012.

Annalaura, Nocentini et al. “Cyberbullying: labels, behaviours and definitionin three European Countries.” Australian Journal of Guidance & Counselling 20 (December 2010):129-147, https://doi.org/10.1375/ajgc.20.2129.

Atticus N. Wegman. “Cyberbullying and California’s Response.” University of San Francisco Law Review 47 (2013): 737-758, https://repository.usfca.edu/usflawreview/vol47/iss4/4.

Bostanci Bozbayindir, Gulsah. “Cyberbullying and criminal law.” Istanbul Hukuk Mecmuasi 77 (2019): 425- 450, https://doi.org/10, 26650.

Christine, Adams, and Jane L. Ireland. “The role of beliefs and trait aggression in prison bullying among youngoffenders.” Journal of Forensic Psychiatry and Psychology29 (2018): 351-367.

Colette, Longos. “Regulation cyberbullying: A South Australian perspective.” Journal of Finding Law, (2013): 73-109, http://www.austlii.edu.au.

Colette, Longos. “Shades of harms.” Psychiatry Psycology and Law 22 (2015): 106-123, https://doi.org/10.1080/13218719.2014.919643.

Dana Lee Ayers. “A legal analisis of cyberbullying with sexting cases.” Ph.D. diss., University of North Carolina, 2016.

Dorofiy, Anastasia. “Bullying among students you can not be silent.” Kyiv National University of Technology and Design, (2020): 211-213, https:// er. Knutd. Edu. Us.

Golamloo Jamshid and Karami, Mohammad. “Stalking; a Comparative Study of Criminal Law of Iran and USA.ˮ Criminal Law and Criminology Studies 50, No. 2 (March 2019): 439-464.[In Persian]

Gupta Mayank, Gupta Nihit, and venessa D SouzaDo. “Antibullying laws in the united state have an impact.” CNS Spectrums, Cambridge University Press, (November 2021): 1-3, https://doi.org/10.1017/S1092852921001012.

Haghighi, Leyla. Moroori bar Jarayeme Cyberi ba Takid bar Ghavanine Mojazate Rayanei, Dovomin Konferanse mellie Rahkarhaye Tosee va Tarvije Amoozeshe Oloom dar Iran, 2015. [In Persian]Haji Deh Abadi, Mohammad Ali, Hoshmand, Poone and Sefidi Sepide. Barresiye Hoghooghi Jormshenasie Harzenegarie Jensie Koodakan. Tehran: Iranian and International Comparative Legal Research, 10, No. 38, (Febriary 2017): 101-134. [In Persian]

Hannah J. Thomas, Jason P. Connor and James G. Scott. “Integrating traditional bullying and Cyberbullying: Challenges of definition and measurement in Adolescents.” Educational psychology Review 29(2014): 135-152, http//doi: 10.1007/s 10648-014-9261-7.

Hillie Byrne, Barbara Dooley, Amanda Fitzgerald and Louise Dolphin. “Adolescents definitions of bullying: the contribution of age, gender and experience of bullying.” European Journal of psychology Education 31(October 2015): 401-418, doi: 10. 1007/s10212-015-0271-8.

Hoseini, Seyyed Hossein, Saleh Abadi, Zahra and Hoseini, Seyede Saede. “Comparative Study of Pornography in Iranian and American Law.ˮ Journal of Comparative Law 15, No. 2 (November 2019): 29-52. [In Persian]

Ilias Kapolsis and Roger. “Case analysis, Hard – core Toughie, Donald Trumps negotiations for the United States presidency.” Negotiation Journal 35 (2019): 47-63, https://doi.org/10.1111/nejo.12263.

Javan Jafari, Abdolreza. “Cyber Crime and Criminal Law Approach to the Differential Looking at the Part Computer Crime Law Islamic.ˮ Journal of Monetary & Financial Economics 17, no. 34 (January 2011): 169-193.[In Persian]

Juan M Acevedo Garcia. “Intentional infliction of emotional distresstorts as the best legal option for victims: when cyberbullying conduct falls throughthe cracks of the U.S. criminal law system.” Revista Jurídica UPR 85 (2016): 127-168, http://revistajuridica.uprrp.edu.

Juliet E. Hart Barnett, Kim W.Fisher, Natasha, Oconnel and Kimberlee Franco. “Promoting upstander behavior to address to bullying in schools.” Middle School Journal 50 (2019): 6-11, https://doi.org/10.1080/00940771.2018.1550377.

Jun F Chisholm. “Review of the status of cyberbullying and cyberbullying prevention.” Journal of Information System Education 25(Spring 2014): 77-78.

Justin W. Patchin and Sameer Hinduja. “Measuring cyberbullying: implication for research.” Aggression and Violent Behavior 23(July–August 2015): 69-74, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.avb.2015.05.013.

Khaleghi, Abolfath and Saleh abadi Zahra. “Study on the Identity Theft in American Federal Law with an Overview to Iran Law.ˮ Journal of Comparative Law 2, no. 4 (November 2015): 87-104. [In Persian]

Kwasi Otopa Antiri. “Types of bullying in the senior high schools Ghana.” Journal of Education and Practice7, No. 36(2016): 131-138, 10.12691/ajnr-6-6-39.

Hudson Jr, David. “Essay: Cyberbullying and Freedom of Speech.” New Mexico Law Review 50, No. 2 (2020): 286-300, https://digitalrepository.unm.edu/nmlr.

Lucie Cor Coran, Conor MC Guckin, and Garry. “Cyberbullying or Cyber Aggression?: A Review of Existing Definitions of Cyber-Based Peer-to-Peer Aggression.” Journal Of Societies 5 (March 2015): 245-255, https://doi.org/10.3390/soc5020245.

Marilyn Campbell, Sheri Bauman. “Cyberbullying definition consequences prevalence.” International Evidence-Based Best Practices in reducing cyberbullying in schools (2018):3-16, https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-811423-0.00001-8.

Patrica Gillen, Marlene Sinclair and W G Kernohan. “A concept analysis of bullying in midwifery.” Evidence Based Midvafery 2 (2004): 46-51, https://pure.ulster.ac.uk.

Paul Nalor, Helen Cowie and Fabienne Cossin. “Teachers and pupils definition of bullying.” British Journal Eduvational Psychology 76 (December 2006): 553-576, https://doi.org/10.1348/000709905X52229.

Peter K. Smith, Cristina Del Barrio and Robert S, Tokunaga. “Definitions of bullying and cyberbullying: how useful are the terms?” In Principles of Cyberbullying Research (New York: London, 2012), 64-86.

QingLi. “Bullying in the new playground, research into cyberbullying and cybervictimisation.” Journal of Educational Technology 23, No. 4 (2007): 435-454, https://doi.org/10.14742/ajet.1245.

Rahimi Mohammad Mehdi, Mahdavi Sabet, Mohammad Ali, Ashoori, Mohammadali and Aghainia, Hosein. “The Crime of Threat in Iranian and American Criminal Law.ˮ Criminal and Private Law Research 14, No. 36(Summer 2017): 75-108. [In Persian] Rostamalizadeh, Saeed and Hamed Haji Mollamirzaie. “Legal System of Internet Filtering in the United States.ˮ Public Law Studies Quarterly 50, No. 4 (Winter 2021): 1663-168. [In Persian]Sad. Ali. Daramadi bar Syasate Filteringe Sythaye Interneti, Faslnameye Motaleate Resanehaye Novin, 2015. [In Persian]

Sanders, Cheryl E, Phye, Gary D. “Bullying Implications for Classroom.” London, Elsevier press (2004).

Serkan Volkan Sari, Faith Camadan. “The new face of violence tendency cyberbullying perpetrators and their victims.” Computers in Human Behavior59 (June 2016): 317-326, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chb.2016.02.027.

Shahghasemi, Ehsan, Basirian Jahromi, Hosein, Almasi Zeynab. Olgooye Pishgiri az Zoorgooie Majazi bar Asase Didgahe Syasatgozaran va Motekhasesan, Satellite Studies and New Media, 2018. [In Persian]

Shaojing Sun.Xitaofan, Jianaia Du. “Cyberbullying perpetration a meta analysis of gender differences.” Internatinal Journal of Internet Science 11(2016):61-81, https://www.ijis.net.

Smith, Alison M. “Protection Of Children Online: Federal And State Laws Addressing Cyberstalking Cyberharrasment And Cyberbullying.” Congressional Research Service (2009).

Tessa M. L. Kaufman, Gijs Huitsing and Rene Veenstra. “Referring victims self reports on bullying assessing frequency, intensity, power imbalance goal directedness.” Social Development 29 (January2020): 375-390, https://doi.org/10.1111/sode.12441.

Vanderblit King, Aliso. “Constitutionality of cyberbullying laws: keeping the online playground safe for both teens and free speech.” Vanderbit Law Review 63 (2010): 844-884, https://home.heinonline.org.

Tony Yang, Erin Grinshteyn. “Safer cyberspace, through legal intervention: A Comparative review of cyberbullying legislation.” World Medical & Health Policy 8(2016): 458-477, https://doi.org/10.1002/wmh3.206.

Youping XU Paula Trazaskawka. “Towards descriptive adequate of cyberbullying interdisciplinary on features, cases and legislation concerns of cyberbullying.” International Journal Semiot Law 34 (2021): 929- 943, https://doi.org/10.1007/s11196-021-09856-4.

Send comment about this article

Name *

Enter Name.

Email Address *

Enter a valid email address.

Affiliation *

Enter a vaid affiliation.

Comments *

Enter comments (At leaset 10 words)

Security Code *