Document Type : Research Article

Authors

1 Professor, Department of Private Law, University of Tehran,, Farabi branch, Qom, Iran.

2 Associated Professor, Department of Private Law,, University of Tehran, Farabi branch,, Qom,, Iran.

3 Ph.D. Student in Private Law, University of Tehran, Farabi branch, Qom, Iran.

Abstract

The business judgment rule as a central and a judicially created doctrine in commercial companies’ law immunes corporate directors from personal liability for decisions they make on behalf of a corporation in order to manage it. There are two approaches about its reliability in American law. According to the first approach, the court can hold directors liable only if their decisions do not correspond with management standards. According to the second approach which is considered as “The Abstention Doctrine”, the courts can’t basically and usually review the board’s decisions and actions. Based on this approach, directors are personally liable against corporation only in special cases. The distinction between these conceptions matters a great deal and essentially comes down to who has the burden of establishing the existence of the factors that would grant or deny business judgment rule protection. In this article, we deal with these two approaches and its differences with Iranians commercial regulations comparatively.

Keywords

-         Aboo salah Halbi, Taghioddin ebne najmoddin (1983). Alkafi fel feghh, Isfahan: General Library of Imam Amiralmomenin. [In Arabic]
-         Allame Helli, Hasan ebne Yoosof ebne Motahare Asadi (1994). Tazkeratol Foghaha, Qom, Alol Beit Institute. [In Arabic]
-         Ansari, Ali (2009). “The Meaning and Concept of Good faith in Iranian and French law”, Comparative Law Researches, Vol. 13, No. 4, pp. 19-64. [In Persian]
-         Ardabili, Ahmad ebne Mohammad (1983). Majmaolfaedeh val borhan fi sharhe ershadel Azhan, Qom: Islamic Publications Office. [In Arabic]
-         Asharif, Mohammad Mahdi & Nasrollah Jafari Khosroabadi (2011). “Nature of Trust”, Law Teacher Magazine, Vol. 40, No. 67, pp. 1-19. [In Persian]
-         Bagheri, Mahmood (2011). The Role of Corporations Law and Stock Market in Privatization Success, Tehran: Islamic Consultative Assembly Research Center. [In Persian]
-          Bainbridge, Stephen M. (2003). “The Business Judgment Rule as Abstention Doctrine”, Law & Economics Research Paper Series, Vol. 57, No. 83, pp. 83-130.
-          Branson, Douglas M (2002). “The Rule that isn’t a Rule, The Business Judgment Rule”, Val. U.L. Rev, Vol. 36, No. 3, pp. 631-654.
-          Cheng, Thomas K. (2011).“The Corporate Veil Doctorine Revisited: A Comporative Study of the English and the U.S. Corporate Veil Doctorines”, B.C. Int'l & Comp. L. Rev,  Issue 2, Vol. 34, pp. 329-412.
-         Darabpoor, Mehrab (2000). Extra Contractual Obligations, Tehran: Majd. [In Persian]
-          Eisenberg, Melvin Aron (1993). “An Overview of the Principles of Corporate Governance”, the Business Lawyer, Vol. 48, No. 4, pp. 1271-1296.
-         Eskini,  Rabia (2004). Commercial law (Commercial Companies),  Fifth Edition, Tehran: Samt. [In Persian]
-         Eskini, Rabia (2003). Commercial law (Commercial Companies), Sixth Edition, Tehran: Samt. [In Persian]
-          Fama. E. (1980). “Agency Problem and the theory of the firm”, Journal of political Economy, Vol. 88, No. 2, pp. 288-307.
-          Fischel, Daniel R. (1982). “The Corporate Governance Movement”, Vanderbilt Law Review, Vol. 35, No. 6, pp. 1259- 1282.
-          Garner, Bryan A. (2011). Black’s Law Dictionary, Third Pocket Edition, United States of America: West Publishing co.
-         Hasanzadeh, Mohammad Mahdi (2011). “The Effects of Yade Amani on the Transactions of Directors of Commercial Companies”, Monthly of Kanoon, No. 123, pp. 15-42. [In Persian]
-          Herman, E.S. (1989). “Corporate Control, Corporate power”, The Economic Journal, Vol. 92, No. 365, pp. xv+432.
-         Isaee Tafreshi, Mohammad (1999). Analytical discussions of commercial corporate law, Tehran: Tarbiat Modares university. [In Persian]
-          Johnson, Lyman P.Q. (2005). “Corporate Officers and the Business Judgment Rule”, the Business Lawyers, Vol. 60, pp. 439-470.
-         Joneydi, Laya & Malihe Zare (2015). “Directors’ Liability Under the Doctrine of Piercing the Corporate Veil: The Directors' Liability for Corporate Debt”, Comparative Law Studies, Vol. 6, No. 1, pp. 85-100. [In Persian]
-         Kamranzade, Nahid (2001). Civil liability of directors of joint stock companies, Master Thesis of Private law, Tehran: Islamic Azad University, central Tehran branch. [In Persian]
-          Lin, Laura (1993). “Shift of Fiduciary Duty upon Corporate Insolvency: Proper Scope of Directors Duty to Creditors”, Vanderbilt Law Review, Vol. 46, pp. 1486-1524.
-          Lori, McMillan (2013). The Business Judgment Rule as an Immunity Doctrine”, Wm. & Mary Bus. L. Rev, Issue 2, Vol. 4, pp. 521-574.
-         Lotfi, Asadollah (1999). “Steeman rule in releasing liability”, Journal of faculty of law university of Tehran, Vol. 44, No. 816, pp. 91-121. [In Persian]
-          Miller, Elizabeth S. & Rutledge, Thomas E. (2005). “The Duty of Finest Loyalty and Reasonable Decisions: The Business Judgment Rule in Unincorporated Business Organization”, Delaware Journal of Corporate Law, Issue 2, Vol. 30, pp. 343-388.
-           Model Business Corporation Act (2003). 3rd Edition, United States: American Bar Association, at 312-988-6102.
-         Pasban, Mohammadreza (2010).“Capacity of commercial companies and limits of authorities of directors of commercial companies”, Journal of Legal Researches, Vol. 13, No. 51, pp. 127-164. [In Persian]
-         Qhomi, Sheikh Abbas (2002). Alghayatolghasva, Qom: Sobhe Piroozi. [In Persian]
-         Sabzevari, Seyed Abdol Aala (1993). Mohazzebel Ahkam, Qom, Al- Manar Institute. [In Arabic]
-         Shaarani, Abolhasan (1998). Tabseratol motaallemin fi ahkame din, Tehran: Manshurate eslamieh. [In Arabic]
-         Shahide Sani, Zeinoddin Ebne Ali (1993). Masalekol afham, Qom, Islamic Knowledge Institute. [In Arabic]
-          Sprague, Robert and Lyttle, Aaron J. (2010). “Shareholder Primacy and the business judgment rule: Arguments for expanded corporate democracy”, Stanford Journal of Law, Business and Finance, Vol. 16, pp. 1-25.
-         Yazdanian, Alireza (2007). Civil law- General rules of civil liability, Tehran: Mizan. [In Persian]
-      Uniform Commercial Code (1952).
-      delawares business judgment rule, international variations«, 08/04/2015, Available at:
 http://global.delaware.gov.
 
CAPTCHA Image